05/05/25 06:01:00
Printable Page
05/05 17:59 CDT Attorney says NCAA deal should resolve judge's concerns over
roster limits, criticizes Saban
Attorney says NCAA deal should resolve judge's concerns over roster limits,
criticizes Saban
By EDDIE PELLS
AP National Writer
An attorney in the $2.8 billion legal case reshaping college sports said Monday
he thinks "the agreement we will reach with the NCAA will solve the judge's
concerns" over roster limits that have delayed final approval.
Steve Berman, co-lead counsel for the defendants, told The Associated Press
that all is on track to file paperwork by Wednesday, which is U.S. District
Judge Claudia Wilken's deadline for addressing concerns that prevented her from
granting approval to the deal last month.
Berman said he created a chart listing the several dozen athletes who lodged
objections to the agreement based on roster limits. He said he thinks almost
every one will be offered a solution.
"We're still negotiating, and I'm confident that everyone who lost a roster
spot will have a chance to get a spot back," he said.
He did not go into detail about whether those spots would be on their previous
teams or new ones.
NCAA vice president of external affairs Tim Buckley said the NCAA would not
comment on the litigation while negotiations are ongoing.
Wilken looked favorably on other key components of the settlement --- namely,
the up to $20.5 million some schools can pay their athletes for name, image
likeness (NIL) deals and the nearly $2.8 billion in back pay that will go to
players who said the NCAA and five biggest conferences wrongly kept them from
earning NIL money.
But she asked lawyers to rework the part of the deal that will replace
scholarship limits with roster limits. It's a proposal that could make more
overall scholarship money available but could cost thousands of athletes their
spots on rosters in moves that began shortly after Wilken gave preliminary
approval to the deal last fall.
The NCAA's first response to Wilken's request --- which included the idea of
"grandfathering in" current players to their roster spots --- was to change
nothing, arguing that undoing roster moves already in play would create more
turmoil in an already chaotic process.
Wilken wasn't moved, saying in her April 24 order that "any disruption that may
occur is a problem of Defendants' and NCAA members schools' own making."
Berman acknowledged that the objectors likely wouldn't approve of the new deal
being worked on.
"But I don't think it's going to be a big deal," he said, because it is
designed to find roster spots for virtually all the individual athletes who
objected.
Attorney: Saban should stay on the sideline
Berman also criticized Nick Saban after reports emerged that the retired
Alabama football coach was urging President Donald Trump to undo damage he says
has been caused by all the money flowing into college sports.
The Wall Street Journal reported Trump is considering an executive order that
would call for some sort of structure behind NIL compensation now going toward
players who are now able to move more freely between schools.
Berman said he believes an executive order would be subject to lawsuits "like
there are against so many of his other orders."
"But here, the question is, ?Why does the president need to get involved?'"
Berman said, while outlining the financial gains players have made in the NIL
era. "Just because Nick Saban thinks he knows better and resents change? This
is a coach who made more money off college football than any other coach, did
absolutely nothing to make it right for these student-athletes. Why should he
drive the president's thinking?"
Saban, who made more than $11 million in his last year at Alabama and who some
have said should become the commissioner of college football --- a position
that doesn't exist --- has said he isn't completely against players making
money.
But he has argued for rules and laws to keep things from looking like the "pay
for play" model that the NCAA hopes to avoid but that is often what NIL
payments look like.
___
AP college sports: https://apnews.com/hub/college-sports
|